Estimated reading time: 4 minutes
Every chain has one. The store that always seems a little behind: lower margin, higher shortages, more turnover, more headaches. Most operators know which store it is. Far fewer know exactly how much it costs them, or why.
The math makes it urgent. NACS reported at its 2026 State of the Industry Summit that after expenses, the average inside transaction lost 7 cents in 2025, and that direct store operating expenses have grown faster than inside gross profit for two years in a row. When the average store is barely breaking even inside, your weakest stores are almost certainly losing money.
Petrosoft runs 22 gas stations of its own, so we rank our stores the same way we recommend here, using CStoreOffice®, SmartPOS, Retail360, QwickServe and Eagle Eye.
The gap between the best and the rest is real
NACS data shows how wide the spread can be. Top-decile companies generate about $8 more gross profit per labor hour than bottom-decile companies, while spending about $5 more per labor hour on wages and benefits. They also kept store manager turnover to 17.1% and employee turnover to 60.8% in the first half of 2025, against an industry average that typically exceeds 100%.
The same spread usually exists inside a single chain. Your best store and your worst store are often running the same products, prices and programs, with very different results.
How Petrosoft helps: CStoreOffice® puts every store’s sales, margin, cash and shift data in one cloud dashboard, so you can rank locations side by side instead of collecting reports from each manager.
The five numbers to rank every store on
- Gross profit per labor hour.
- Average basket size (the NACS average was $7.69 in 2025).
- Foodservice share of inside sales (28.5% industry average, per NACS).
- Voids, refunds, no-sales and cash shortages per 1,000 transactions.
- Store manager and employee turnover.
A store that ranks low on two or more of these is your priority. One weak number is a coaching conversation. Three is a problem.
When the gap is basket size
Labor costs about $1.60 per inside transaction, according to NACS. A store with a smaller basket spends the same on every transaction and earns less from it.
How Petrosoft helps: QwickServe self-order kiosks help lagging stores build a food program that adds to the basket, and CStoreOffice® centralized price books make sure every store runs the same promotions at the right prices on SmartPOS.
When the gap is shrink
The NRF and Loss Prevention Research Council found 40% of retailers saw more organized retail crime in 2025, 50% saw more repeat offenders and 63% report fewer than half of store theft incidents to police. A single high-shrink store can quietly wipe out the profit of a good one.
How Petrosoft helps: Eagle Eye ties video to SmartPOS transactions, so your team can review a lagging store’s exceptions without driving there. CStoreOffice® cash and shift controls show which shifts drive the shortages.
When the gap is the manager
Top-decile chains keep managers longer. Sometimes the weakest store simply needs a stable leader and better coaching.
How Petrosoft helps: Retail360 gives district managers and store managers the same numbers on their phones, so every coaching conversation starts from facts.
The 90-day turnaround checklist
- Rank every store on the five numbers in CStoreOffice®.
- Pick the bottom two stores and identify their weakest numbers.
- Fix basket gaps with QwickServe food and consistent SmartPOS pricing.
- Fix shrink gaps with Eagle Eye exception reviews every week.
- Coach managers weekly using Retail360.
- Re-rank every 30 days and track the gap closing.
Frequently asked questions
How do I compare performance across my convenience stores?
Rank every store on the same set of numbers: gross profit per labor hour, basket size, foodservice share, exceptions like voids and shortages, and turnover. CStoreOffice® puts these side by side for every location.
What is a good average basket size for a c-store?
NACS reported the average c-store basket was $7.69 in 2025. Compare each of your stores to that number and to your own best store.
How much more do top c-store companies earn per labor hour?
NACS found top-decile companies earn about $8 more gross profit per labor hour than bottom-decile companies.
What should I do about my worst-performing store?
Find its two or three weakest numbers, fix those first, and re-rank every 30 days. Most underperformance comes from a few specific gaps, not everything at once.
Does Petrosoft use store benchmarking in its own stations?
Yes. Petrosoft runs 22 gas stations and ranks them using CStoreOffice® and Retail360.
See every store side by side in CStoreOffice®. Book a live, no-pressure demo at petrosoftinc.com.
Sources
- NACS Magazine, “5 Big Takeaways From the 2026 NACS State of the Industry Summit” (June 2026): https://nacsmagazine.com/issues/june-2026/nacs-state-of-the-industry-summit-2026-takeaways
- NACS, “Key Metrics for a C-Store Employee Retention Strategy” (January 2026): https://www.convenience.org/stay-current/news/2026/january/30/3-key-metrics-for-c-store-employee-retention_nacs
- NACS, “U.S. Convenience In-Store Sales Top $340 Billion” (State of the Industry, April 2026): https://www.convenience.org/stay-current/news/2026/april/15/u-s-convenience-in-store-sales-top-$340-billion
- NRF & Loss Prevention Research Council, The Impact of Retail Theft & Violence 2026 (July 2026): https://nrf.com/media-center/press-releases/retailers-see-fraud-schemes-evolve-as-shoplifting-declines-nrf-study-finds