Experience a no pressure, live demo of our software.   Talk with our sales team

Big-Box Fuel Is Winning Over Your Older Customers. How Fuel Retailers Fight Back 

Estimated reading time: 4 minutes

One number from the 2026 NACS Consumer Survey should get every fuel retailer’s attention: 38% of consumers 65 and older now buy fuel from big-box retailers, up 16 points from a year earlier. Overall, 79% of consumers still prefer c-stores for refueling, but that’s down six points from 2025. 

Big-box retailers have scale on their side. The NRF forecast 2026 retail sales growth of 4.4% to more than $5.6 trillion, and the biggest players use cheap fuel to pull shoppers onto their lots. Meanwhile, NACS reports fuel was 65% of c-store sales dollars in 2025 but only 38.8% of gross profit, so most fuel retailers can’t simply out-discount them. 

Petrosoft runs 22 gas stations of its own, and we compete with big-box fuel every day. Here’s how fuel retailers and jobbers can fight back with Retail360, CStoreOffice®, SmartPOS, QwickServe and Eagle Eye. 

1. Know your real price floor 

You can’t win a price war you can’t afford. Every cent you match has to come out of a margin that’s already thin, and card fees keep rising. The NRF reports U.S. businesses paid $198.25 billion in swipe fees in 2025, and NACS puts the convenience industry’s share at a record $21.3 billion. 

How Petrosoft helps: CStoreOffice® shows true fuel margin by site using real delivered costs from EDI fuel invoices, so you know exactly how far you can go. Retail360 puts fuel performance on your phone so you can respond to competitor moves quickly. 

2. Win on rewards, not just the street price 

When NACS asked shoppers which loyalty rewards they value most, gas savings or cents off per gallon came first at 45.2%, followed by coupons at 44.2%. And 53% of loyalty members say a program makes them more likely to shop a c-store. Targeted fuel rewards can match a big-box price for your regulars without cutting the price for everyone. 

How Petrosoft helps: SmartPOS records fuel and inside sales in the same transactions, so CStoreOffice® can show whether a fuel reward is bringing customers back and growing the inside basket. 

3. Be faster and easier 

Three in four consumers plan their c-store visits, and 40% refuel at least weekly, according to NACS. Big-box fuel often means long lines and a detour. A quick, clean, easy stop is a real advantage, especially for older drivers. 

How Petrosoft helps: SmartPOS keeps checkout fast inside, and Eagle Eye ties video to transactions so managers can keep the forecourt and store safe and running smoothly. 

4. Give them something big-box fuel can’t 

62% of consumers went inside the last time they bought gas (NACS), and nearly 30% of shoppers say “I’m hungry” is their main reason for choosing a store. A big-box fuel island can’t make a fresh breakfast sandwich. 

How Petrosoft helps: QwickServe self-order kiosks and kitchen displays make fresh food fast and accurate, turning a fuel stop into a reason to choose you. 

5. Never run out 

Nothing sends a regular to the big-box lot faster than bagged nozzles. Reliable supply is part of loyalty. 

How Petrosoft helps: Retail360 fuel forecasting helps schedule loads before you need them, and CStoreOffice® ATG-integrated wet-stock reconciliation keeps inventory numbers accurate. 

The fuel retailer’s big-box defense checklist 

  1. Calculate your true price floor by site in CStoreOffice®. 
  2. Use targeted fuel rewards for regulars instead of across-the-board cuts. 
  3. Measure whether rewards grow inside sales, not just gallons. 
  4. Add fresh food with QwickServe to give drivers a reason to stop. 
  5. Keep checkout fast with SmartPOS. 
  6. Forecast fuel demand with Retail360 so you never run out. 

Frequently asked questions 

Are big-box retailers taking fuel customers from gas stations? 

NACS’s 2026 Consumer Survey found 38% of consumers 65 and older now buy fuel from big-box retailers, up 16 points in a year. 79% of consumers still prefer c-stores for fuel, down six points from 2025. 

How can a gas station compete with big-box fuel prices? 

Know your true price floor, use targeted fuel rewards for regulars, compete on speed and convenience, and give customers reasons to come inside, like fresh food. 

What loyalty rewards do fuel customers want most? 

NACS Convenience Voices data shows gas savings or cents off per gallon is the most valued reward at 45.2%. 

Should I match big-box gas prices? 

Only if you know your true net margin after card fees. Matching below your floor means losing money on every gallon. CStoreOffice® shows true margin by site. 

What can a c-store offer that big-box fuel can’t? 

Fresh food, a faster stop and a store experience. NACS reports 62% of consumers went inside the last time they bought gas. 

See how Retail360, CStoreOffice® and QwickServe help you compete with big-box fuel. Book a live, no-pressure demo at petrosoftinc.com. 

Sources

With just a few minutes of your time, see live and in action how Petrosoft increases profits and simplifies business operations. No pressure, ask any questions you like!