Loyalty is one of the biggest advantages a chain has over a single store. When NACS asked shoppers which c-store loyalty rewards they value most, 39.7% picked points they can earn and redeem across multiple locations. Only a chain can offer that.
Shoppers are paying attention. NACS found 63.3% of shoppers started using loyalty programs, coupons or promotions in 2025, and 53% of loyalty members say a program makes them more likely to shop a c-store. But the NRF and Loss Prevention Research Council found 51% of retailers saw more loyalty fraud in 2025. Loyalty is valuable, and that makes it a target.
Petrosoft runs 22 gas stations of its own, so we know a loyalty program is only as good as the data behind it. Here’s how chains use CStoreOffice®, SmartPOS, Retail360, QwickServe and Eagle Eye to make loyalty profitable and protected.
What shoppers value most
- Gas savings or cents off per gallon: 45.2%.
- Coupons or digital coupons: 44.2%.
- Points earned and redeemed across multiple locations: 39.7%.
That’s NACS Convenience Voices data, and it points to one strategy: reward fuel and inside purchases together, everywhere in your network.
How Petrosoft helps: SmartPOS records fuel and inside sales in the same transaction data, and CStoreOffice® brings every store’s results into one view, so you can measure what each reward really costs and earns.
Fight for the food visit
NACS reports one in three c-store customers visits a quick-service restaurant within 30 minutes of leaving a c-store. Food rewards are one of the best ways to win that visit back, and foodservice already drives 38.9% of in-store profit.
How Petrosoft helps: QwickServe self-order kiosks make food ordering fast and accurate at every location, and every order lands in CStoreOffice® so you can track which food rewards bring people back.
Measure margin, not just signups
A loyalty program can grow traffic and still lose money if discounts are too deep or aimed at the wrong items. Chains need to see promotion results by store, by item and by day.
How Petrosoft helps: CStoreOffice® centralized price books and promotion reporting show how each offer affects units, basket and margin across the chain. Retail360 puts those results in district managers’ hands.
Protect the program
Beyond loyalty fraud, NRF found 42% of retailers saw more gift card theft or fraud and 40% more organized retail crime. Unusual discount patterns at one store or on one shift are often the first sign of trouble.
How Petrosoft helps: Eagle Eye ties video to SmartPOS transactions, so your team can quickly review suspicious discounts, refunds and gift card activity at any location.
The chain loyalty checklist
- Offer rewards that work at every store in your network.
- Pair fuel savings with inside purchases and measure the margin in CStoreOffice®.
- Use food rewards with QwickServe to win back quick-service visits.
- Review promotion results by store and item every week.
- Watch discount and refund patterns and verify outliers with Eagle Eye.
- Give district managers Retail360 so they can act fast.
Frequently asked questions
What loyalty rewards do convenience store shoppers want most?
NACS Convenience Voices data shows gas savings or cents off per gallon (45.2%), coupons or digital coupons (44.2%) and points earned and redeemed across multiple locations (39.7%).
Do loyalty programs bring more customers to c-stores?
Yes. NACS found 53% of loyalty members say a program makes them more likely to shop a c-store.
How common is loyalty fraud?
The NRF and Loss Prevention Research Council found 51% of retailers reported more loyalty fraud in 2025.
How do I know if my loyalty program is profitable?
Measure promotions by margin and basket size, not just traffic, and compare results by store. CStoreOffice® brings this data together for every location.
How can chains prevent loyalty and discount fraud?
Monitor discounts, refunds and gift card activity by store and shift, and review outliers with video. Eagle Eye links video to SmartPOS transactions for exactly this.
See how CStoreOffice® helps chains measure and protect every promotion. Book a live, no-pressure demo at petrosoftinc.com.
Sources
- NACS, “Today’s Convenience Shopper” (Convenience Voices data, September 2026): https://convenience.org/stay-current/conveniencecorner/todays-convenience-shopper
- NACS Magazine, “Who’s Buying Your Gas?” (2026 NACS Consumer Survey, April 2026): https://www.nacsmagazine.com/Issues/April-2026/Who’s-Buying-Your-Gas
- NACS Magazine, “5 Big Takeaways From the 2026 NACS State of the Industry Summit” (June 2026): https://nacsmagazine.com/issues/june-2026/nacs-state-of-the-industry-summit-2026-takeaways
- NRF & Loss Prevention Research Council, The Impact of Retail Theft & Violence 2026 (July 2026): https://nrf.com/media-center/press-releases/retailers-see-fraud-schemes-evolve-as-shoplifting-declines-nrf-study-finds